Memberships and subscriptions
Disciple vs Givebutter compared on 10 fields
- Disciple score
- 64/100 (6 of 7 criteria)
- Givebutter score
- 86/100 (5 of 7 criteria)
- Fields won by Disciple
- 0 of 5
- Fields won by Givebutter
- 3 of 5
Disciple
Givebutter
Data checked Oct 14, 2026 against the vendors' own pages. How we verify
Disciple and Givebutter are both membership platforms. We compared them on 10 fields read from each vendor's own pages.
On the membership platforms scorecard Disciple scores 64/100 (6 of 7 criteria) and Givebutter 86/100 (5 of 7 criteria) (ranks 17 and 7 in the category).
Of the 5 fields with a clear rule (lower price, higher count, yes over no), Disciple wins 0, Givebutter wins 3 and 2 are ties.
Givebutter scores clearly higher on entry price and free plan or trial.
Side by side
| Field | Disciple | Givebutter | Winner and basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cheapest paid plan (billed monthly) | $599/month | ✓ $29/month | Givebutter |
| Same plan, per month billed annually | $599/month | – | No winner: needs a value on both sides |
| Free plan | No | ✓ Yes | Givebutter |
| Free trial | Yes | Yes | Tie |
| Integrations (vendor count) | 100 | ✓ 1,000 | Givebutter |
| Public API | Yes | – | No winner: needs a value on both sides |
| Data export | Members, posts and analytics can be exported in full | Financial reports, payout reconciliations and data exports | No winner: no rule for this field |
| Analytics | Yes | Yes | Tie |
| Team access | Yes | – | No winner: needs a value on both sides |
| AI assistant | – | Yes | No winner: needs a value on both sides |
– = not published by the vendor, or not verified yet.
Sources: Disciple pricing page, checked Oct 14, 2026; Givebutter pricing page, checked Oct 14, 2026. Each feature value links its own source on the tool's page.
Scorecard, criterion by criterion
| Criterion | Weight | Disciple | Givebutter |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | 25% | 0$599/month billed annually on Off the shelf Branded App; no monthly-billed price published (scored against annual-billed prices) | 60$29/month billed monthly on Givebutter Plus (scored on the monthly price) |
| Free plan or trial | 15% | 60Free trial, no free plan | 100Free plan (Free) |
| Pricing transparency | 10% | 1003 of 3 plans have a public price | 932 of 2 plans have a public price |
| Verified features | 15% | 1002 of 4 tracked features verified: analytics, team access | 1002 of 4 tracked features verified: analytics, ai assistant |
| API, integrations and export | 10% | 100public API, 100 integrations, documented data export | 1001,000 integrations, documented data export |
| Members per plan | 10% | 100Unlimited members on Off the shelf Branded App ($599/month) | – |
| Total score | 100% | 64/100 (6 of 7 criteria) | 86/100 (5 of 7 criteria) |
Disciple plans
| Plan | Billed monthly | Billed yearly | Charged per | Published limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Off the shelf Branded App | Not offered | $599 | per workspace |
|
| Off the shelf Branded App Pro | Not offered | $999 | per workspace |
|
| Business partnership Organisation | Not offered | $3,400 | per workspace | None stated |
Prices in USD per month, before tax. Read from the vendor's pricing page on Oct 14, 2026. "Not stated" means the page does not publish it.
Givebutter plans
| Plan | Billed monthly | Billed yearly | Charged per | Published limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Free | Free | Free | per workspace |
|
| Givebutter Plus | $29 | Not stated | per workspace | None stated |
Prices in USD per month, before tax. Read from the vendor's pricing page on Oct 14, 2026. "Not stated" means the page does not publish it.
How we picked
Every one of these membership platforms is scored by the same 7 criteria (scorecard v1). Each criterion gives 0 to 100 from the vendor's published data; the total is the weighted average. A criterion without verified data is left out and the other weights are re-normalised. A tool with under 60% of the weight covered is listed as not ranked, and so is a tool with no verified price and fewer than 2 verified features (“needs a verified price”); each score shows how many criteria it is based on. The core criteria are the same in every category; the category criteria are specific to membership platforms. Nobody gets custom weights, including our own products.
| Criterion | Weight | Type | What we measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | 25% | Core | Price per month of the cheapest paid plan, against the prices of other membership platforms on the same billing basis (monthly-billed prices against monthly, annual-billed against annual).Log scale. Billed monthly: $15/month or less = 100, $79 or more = 0. Only billed annually: $15.83/month or less = 100, $89 or more = 0. Only free plans = 100. Usage-priced and one-time plans are not scored. |
| Free plan or trial | 15% | Core | Whether you can use the tool before paying: a free plan, or failing that a free trial, as shown on the vendor's pricing page.Free plan = 100. No free plan but a free trial = 60. The pricing page lists plans but shows neither = 0. No plans read = not scored. |
| Pricing transparency | 10% | Core | How much of the pricing is public: the share of plans with a published price ("contact sales" counts against), and whether there are at least 3 published tiers.80 x (plans with a public price / plans listed) + 20 x (public plans, up to 3) / 3. No plans read = not scored. |
| Verified features | 15% | Core | How many of the 4 features we track for this category the vendor's own pages verifiably show (analytics, team access, templates, ai assistant). This counts verified features only: a tool that documents less scores lower here, and only here.Linear: verified features / 2 (half the tracked list) x 100, capped at 100. No tracked feature verified = not scored. |
| API, integrations and export | 10% | Core | Whether a public API exists, how many integrations the vendor states, and whether the vendor documents a way to export your data.Average of the parts with data: public API yes = 100, no = 0; integrations on a log scale (100 or more = 100); a documented data export = 100. None verified = not scored. |
| Fee on sales | 15% | Category | The percentage of each sale the platform keeps, as the vendor states it (the cheapest paid plan that states a fee).Linear, lower is better: 0% = 100, 10% or more = 0. No stated fee = not scored. |
| Members per plan | 10% | Category | Members included on the cheapest paid plan that states a limit.Log scale: 1,000 or more (or unlimited) = 100. No stated limit = not scored. |
Sources are vendor pricing pages, docs and changelogs, each with the date we checked it. We did not test these tools hands-on unless a listing says so. Full formulas: methodology.
Questions, answered from the data
Is Disciple cheaper than Givebutter?
Givebutter starts lower: $29 per month billed monthly on the Givebutter Plus plan, against $599 per month billed yearly on the Off the shelf Branded App plan for Disciple. Check the unit: per-user and per-account prices scale differently.
Do Disciple and Givebutter have free plans?
Givebutter has a free plan; Disciple does not.
Which is better, Disciple or Givebutter?
On our scorecard Givebutter scores higher (86/100 (5 of 7 criteria) vs 64/100 (6 of 7 criteria)). The score weighs every criterion the same way for every tool; check the rows above for the ones that matter to you.