Memberships and subscriptions
Top Givebutter competitors 10 competitors in Givebutter's market
- Competitors listed
- 10
- Ranked on the scorecard
- 8
- Givebutter's rank
- #7 of 23
- With a free plan
- 3
Data checked Oct 14, 2026 against the vendors' own pages. How we verify
These are the 10 tools closest to Givebutter in its own market: membership platforms that list memberships and subscriptions too, picked by shared categories and how close their entry price is to Givebutter's (the rules are below).
8 of them are ranked on the membership platforms scorecard; Insidr is the highest at 89/100 (#6 of 23 in the category).
Givebutter itself is #7 of 23 with 86/100, so 1 competitor on this list ranks above it.
Givebutter's cheapest paid plan is $29 billed monthly (Givebutter Plus). On the same billing basis, 1 of 5 competitors with a published price start lower and 4 start higher; entry plans are not like-for-like, so check the limits.
3 competitors have a free plan, and so does Givebutter.
Givebutter vs its competitors: market position
| Rank | Tool | Score | From, billed monthly | From, billed yearly | Free plan | Public API | Integrations | Features verified | Data checked |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #7 | GivebutterThis tool | 86/100 | $29/mo | Not offered | Yes, unlimited users | – | 1,000 | 2 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #6 |  Insidr | 89/100 | Free | Free | Yes | – | – | 1 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #13 |  MemberPress | 69/100 | Not offered | $16.63/mo | No | Yes | – | 1 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #14 |  Heartbeat | 67/100 | $49/mo | $40/mo | No | Yes | – | 2 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #15 |  Circle | 64/100 | Not offered | $89/mo | No | Yes | – | 3 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #17 |  Disciple | 64/100 | Not offered | $599/mo | No | Yes | 100 | 2 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #19 |  Donorbox | 62/100 | $150/mo | Not offered | Yes, 5 users | Yes | – | 3 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #21 |  Wild Apricot | 61/100 | $66/mo | $59.40/mo | No | Yes | 1,600 | 2 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| #22 |  Memberful | 55/100 | $49/mo | Not offered | No | Yes | – | 2 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
| – |  Podfan | Not ranked | $12/mo | Not offered | Yes | – | – | – | Oct 14, 2026 |
| – |  Supercast | Not ranked | Contact sales | Contact sales | No | Yes | – | 1 of 4 | Oct 14, 2026 |
Each value links the page it was read from (hover for the check date).
– = not published by the vendor, or not verified yet.
How each competitor differs from Givebutter
- Insidr · #6, 89/100
Direct-to-fan subscription platform where musicians charge fans a monthly price for released and unreleased music and behind-the-scenes content, with an app and artist dashboard.
- Score: 89/100, #6 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: free; no paid plans published source
- Verified features: Analytics
3 of 8 tracked details verified
Homepage captured Oct 14, 2026 - MemberPress · #13, 69/100
WordPress plugin that adds membership sites, paywalled content, subscription billing, online courses and coaching tools to a site.
- Score: 69/100, #13 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: $16.63 per month billed annually; not compared with Givebutter, which publishes no price on the same billing basis source
- Free plan: no (Givebutter: yes) source
- Verified features: AI assistant, Public API
3 of 8 tracked details verified
- Heartbeat · #14, 67/100
Community platform that combines discussion channels, courses, events, payments and a branded app for people who sell memberships.
- Score: 67/100, #14 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: $49 billed monthly (Build), $20 more than Givebutter's $29 source
- Free plan: no (Givebutter: yes) source
- Matches Givebutter: has all 2 features we verified for Givebutter
4 of 8 tracked details verified
- Circle · #15, 64/100
Platform for running a member community with courses, live events, payments and a website under your own brand, with an AI assistant.
- Score: 64/100, #15 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: $89 per month billed annually; not compared with Givebutter, which publishes no price on the same billing basis source
- Free plan: no (Givebutter: yes) source
- Matches Givebutter: has all 2 features we verified for Givebutter
5 of 8 tracked details verified
- Disciple · #17, 64/100
White-labelled community platform that lets organisations launch their own branded iOS, Android and web app with feeds, groups, events, livestreams and courses.
- Score: 64/100, #17 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: $599 per month billed annually; not compared with Givebutter, which publishes no price on the same billing basis source
- Free plan: no (Givebutter: yes) source
- Integrations: 100 (Givebutter: 1,000) source
- Verified features: Analytics, Team access, Public API
6 of 8 tracked details verified
- Donorbox · #19, 62/100
Fundraising software for nonprofits offering donation forms, donation pages, recurring giving, events, peer-to-peer campaigns and a donor CRM.
- Score: 62/100, #19 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: $150 billed monthly (Pro), $121 more than Givebutter's $29 source
- Matches Givebutter: has all 2 features we verified for Givebutter
5 of 8 tracked details verified
- Wild Apricot · #21, 61/100
Membership management software for associations, nonprofits and clubs covering a member database, events, email, a website builder and payments.
- Score: 61/100, #21 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: $66 billed monthly (100 Contacts), $37 more than Givebutter's $29 source
- Free plan: no (Givebutter: yes) source
- Integrations: 1,600 (Givebutter: 1,000) source
- Verified features: Analytics, Templates, Public API
5 of 8 tracked details verified
- Memberful · #22, 55/100
Membership platform for creators, publishers and communities to sell paid subscriptions and gated content on their own site through their own Stripe account.
- Score: 55/100, #22 of 23 (Givebutter: 86/100, #7)
- Entry price: $49 billed monthly (Standard), $20 more than Givebutter's $29 source
- Free plan: no (Givebutter: yes) source
- Verified features: Analytics, Team access, Public API
4 of 8 tracked details verified
- Podfan
Platform for podcasters that provides a podcast page and sells paid memberships, donations and private member-only feeds, with payments handled through Stripe.
- Score: not ranked (50% coverage)
- Entry price: $12 billed monthly (Essential), $17 less than Givebutter's $29 source
- In numbers: 3 published plans and a free plan. source
1 of 8 tracked details verified
- Supercast
Podcast subscription platform that hosts premium feeds and handles listener sign-up and billing through the creator's own Stripe account.
- Score: not ranked (50% coverage)
- Entry price: contact sales (no published price) source
- Free plan: no (Givebutter: yes) source
- Verified features: Analytics, Public API
3 of 8 tracked details verified
Givebutter head to head
How we picked
- Pool: tools in the same market as the tool on this page: they list its primary category, and their own primary category is one it lists too. Explicit competitor links count as well.
- Closest first, at most 10: explicit competitors, then the same primary category, then more shared categories, then the smallest gap in entry price (per month, on a log scale), then more shared platforms, then name.
- Order on the page: tools ranked on the category scorecard by their category rank, then tools that are not ranked (no scorecard, or under 60% of the weight with verified data) in closeness order.
- Prices are compared only on the same billing basis (billed monthly with billed monthly, billed annually with billed annually). A feature counts as missing only when the vendor's page states it; a feature the vendor does not mention is not listed either way.
Every value is read from the vendor's own pages (or GitHub for licences and stars) and shown with the date we checked it. A value we could not verify is shown as a dash, never estimated, and never read as a “no”. We did not test these tools hands-on unless a listing says so. Methodology
The scorecard behind the ranks
Every one of these membership platforms is scored by the same 7 criteria (scorecard v1). Each criterion gives 0 to 100 from the vendor's published data; the total is the weighted average. A criterion without verified data is left out and the other weights are re-normalised. A tool with under 60% of the weight covered is listed as not ranked, and so is a tool with no verified price and fewer than 2 verified features (“needs a verified price”); each score shows how many criteria it is based on. The core criteria are the same in every category; the category criteria are specific to membership platforms. Nobody gets custom weights, including our own products.
| Criterion | Weight | Type | What we measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Entry price | 25% | Core | Price per month of the cheapest paid plan, against the prices of other membership platforms on the same billing basis (monthly-billed prices against monthly, annual-billed against annual).Log scale. Billed monthly: $15/month or less = 100, $79 or more = 0. Only billed annually: $15.83/month or less = 100, $89 or more = 0. Only free plans = 100. Usage-priced and one-time plans are not scored. |
| Free plan or trial | 15% | Core | Whether you can use the tool before paying: a free plan, or failing that a free trial, as shown on the vendor's pricing page.Free plan = 100. No free plan but a free trial = 60. The pricing page lists plans but shows neither = 0. No plans read = not scored. |
| Pricing transparency | 10% | Core | How much of the pricing is public: the share of plans with a published price ("contact sales" counts against), and whether there are at least 3 published tiers.80 x (plans with a public price / plans listed) + 20 x (public plans, up to 3) / 3. No plans read = not scored. |
| Verified features | 15% | Core | How many of the 4 features we track for this category the vendor's own pages verifiably show (analytics, team access, templates, ai assistant). This counts verified features only: a tool that documents less scores lower here, and only here.Linear: verified features / 2 (half the tracked list) x 100, capped at 100. No tracked feature verified = not scored. |
| API, integrations and export | 10% | Core | Whether a public API exists, how many integrations the vendor states, and whether the vendor documents a way to export your data.Average of the parts with data: public API yes = 100, no = 0; integrations on a log scale (100 or more = 100); a documented data export = 100. None verified = not scored. |
| Fee on sales | 15% | Category | The percentage of each sale the platform keeps, as the vendor states it (the cheapest paid plan that states a fee).Linear, lower is better: 0% = 100, 10% or more = 0. No stated fee = not scored. |
| Members per plan | 10% | Category | Members included on the cheapest paid plan that states a limit.Log scale: 1,000 or more (or unlimited) = 100. No stated limit = not scored. |
Sources are vendor pricing pages, docs and changelogs, each with the date we checked it. We did not test these tools hands-on unless a listing says so. Full formulas: methodology.
Questions, answered from the data
Who are Givebutter's main competitors?
By our scorecard, the highest-ranked of its closest competitors are Insidr (89/100), MemberPress (69/100) and Heartbeat (67/100).
Which Givebutter competitor is cheapest?
Billed monthly, Podfan starts lowest at $12 a month (Essential). Entry plans differ in limits.
How does Givebutter rank against its competitors?
Givebutter is #7 of 23 ranked membership platforms with 86/100.
Which Givebutter competitors have a free plan?
Insidr, Donorbox and Podfan.